Cast member James Marsden attends the premiere of the film "Cats & Dogs, The Revenge of Kitty Galore" in Los Angeles July 25, 2010. REUTERS/Phil McCarten

After the true love's kiss in "Enchanted", fans have been eagerly anticipating a sequel to the fairytale blockbuster.

James Marsden, who plays the dashing Prince Edward in the family-friendly movie, talks to Marc Malkin of E! Online about the likelihood of Enchanted 2 coming to theatres.

"We all hoped it would happen. I don't understand why they never did it. It was a very successful movie," Marsden says.

While fairytale lovers may enjoy watching the lovable characters portrayed once again on the big screen, the clock is ticking for Marsden and his co-star Amy Adams.

"But at some point when the gray hairs start coming, you can't really play the quintessential animated prince anymore. Amy and I were like, 'If we're going to do it, we should do it before we're 40,'" he shares good-naturedly.

"If it happens, great! If not, what are you going to do?" he adds.

Marsden, 38, seems to be geared up to star in another Enchanted flick, but in the meantime, he's keeping busy with other projects.

His latest flick "Straw Dogs" is a remake of the 1971 controversial psychological thriller, and it is a lot more sinister than the child-favorite Enchanted.

"I'm not a method actor but this was the most psychologically intense I've taken myself on any performance," Marsden tells ET Online.

Despite the hard work that went into filming, it remained a hit-and-miss among critics.

On one hand, Star Tribune's Colin Covert calls on Marsden's weak performance saying he's "a nice light comedian out of his depth in a role requiring powerhouse dramatic chops."

A more complimentary review praises the actor - and his co-star - as he takes over Dustin Hoffman's iconic character.

"But Kate Bosworth and, especially, James Marsden are excellent as Amy and David Sumner," Elizabeth Weitzman writes in her review at New York Daily News.

The actor is keeping all of the feedback in perspective - at arm's length.

"Obviously I want my movies to do well and for people to dig my work, but at some point it's out of your power. It's your responsibility as an actor to deliver a performance that you're proud of," Marsden explains.