- Oil expert Dian L. Chu believes investors/speculators are dominating the direction of oil prices - The thesis will be put to a test as futures contracts will roll over later this month - Chu believes persistently high oil prices will again attract the attention of market regulators

Oil Market Speculation Argument to be Tested by WTI Rollover Cycle

Guest commentary by Dian L. Chu, EconMatters,

The monthly roll cycle starts Tuesday April 5th for Crude Oil with the 4-day rolling of USO positions, the USO is an exchange traded security meant to track movements in the WTI futures contract. This happens over a four day period now from the 5th-8th of April, so that traders cannot easily front-run the rollover process.

Rolling, Rolling, Rolling - USO, Brent & WTI

Nevertheless, obviously with the price of Crude rising, the USO has to sell a lot of front month longs in the May contract to rollover to the June contract. Based on the listed holdings as of Monday April 4, USO will roll over 8,400 WTI Crude Futures for the May contract on the ICE exchange, and also has to rollover 8,821 CL Crude Futures for the May contract on the Nymex exchange, and 2,000 Crd. Oil Fincl. Futures WS for May also on the Nymex exchange.

Next we have the Brent contract Rollover schedule which begins with options that expire on the 12th of April with the futures contract expiring on the 15th of April. However, expect traders to position ahead of the actual expiration date as most traders will roll their Brent futures contracts sometime between the 8th and the 13th and for options the 8th through the 12th serves as a good rule of thumb.

For the WTI rollover we have options expiring on the 14th of April, and futures on the 19th of April, but again most of the rollover takes place prior to the last 2 days of the date of expiration. So expect most traders to rollover positions somewhere between the 12th through the 15th of April. For options activity it would be the 12th through the 14th.

Trader Rolling Technique

The roll methodology can take several different directions according to trader's expectations. Besides the procedural roll of the USO, which over 4 days they sell May contracts and buy June contracts in the same instruments; however, for the rest of the traders there is more discretion involved.

For example, often times traders know that a large base of positions have to be rolled over, so they close out their positions, and wait for the selling to end before then buying the next month's contract to keep their original bias in the market. Some traders even short the market at the same time they are closing out their original longs because they know that a large roll of longs will be closed out, so they piggy back on the rollover for additional profits.

This is oftentimes why you experience 4 or 5 days of weakness due to the selling, and shorts piggybacking on the rollover, with two days of strength in the expiring contract as the shorts have to go long to close out their positions before the contract expires.

Recent Rollover Pattern

If we look at recent contract rollovers for the last several months, the pattern has been to move up the futures contract from the last two days of the expiring contract, and right up until the USO starts the entire rollover sequence again. As such, most of the gains for each new month come right at the beginning of the next month’s contract being the front month.

The reason for this is apparent, as new money can come into the contract with new positions without the worries of having to rollover their position or take physical delivery. Again, we saw this with this month's contract, so the pattern is holding.

Test Case for Market Speculation

However, we have an interesting test case for markets, and the long standing argument that markets are never run-over by speculators, because in the end, all market participants have to take physical delivery or close out their positions, so they cannot affect price over the long term.

Well, with Cushing inventories at record highs, literally bursting at the seams (see charts below), and only going to get worse over the next two weeks, and given the fact that the WTI contract is deliverable at the Cushing hub, we will finally test whether that hypothesis is true.

No Storage = Close Out Long Positions

In other words, there is no way traders can take delivery on enough crude for the expiring May contract to not go down from current levels, because there isn't sufficient storage capacity. Anybody who opened a new position for the May contract, and there were lots of newly created long positions with a rising oil price for this contract, must close out these longs by selling the May contract, thus making the front month go down.

The reason it is a test is that unless traders arrange for a bunch of tanker trucks to back up to the Cushing hub, which is mighty expensive and cumbersome, also considerations of what you do with the Oil after taking delivery, i.e., major additional transportation and storage costs, and the WTI contract doesn't go down, we now know that the taking physical delivery argument is an invalid argument.

Spotlight on Speculators If Oil Price Still Moves Up

Moreover, there are ways to move up futures contracts without taking physical delivery. All of which would shine a bright spotlight on the role and power of speculators in driving up Oil prices, and how previous regulations have failed to address the major divergences between the underlying supplies in the market, and the prices reflected by the futures contracts trading on the exchanges.

It seems that if we look back at 2008 where Oil prices basically went from $143 to$33 a barrel in six months, and Oil being a rather inelastic commodity, that some of the practices that go on in regard to speculation in this commodity, have been stubbornly neglected and overlooked by regulators.

Oil Market - Vegas Style Casino

If these boom and bust price spikes continue, they are not truly reflective of underlying fundamentals. As they push markets in both directions far past the underlying supply and demand dynamics of the market, this price instability isn't good for consumers, producers, exporters, importers, refiners and the global economy.

Having a healthy, stable Oil market devoid of excessive speculation is in everyone's best interest over the long haul. What the regulatory framework needed to accomplish this lofty goal is another matter entirely.

However, one thing is for certain--the Oil market reflects more of the characteristics of a Las Vegas Casino game, and less the characteristics of a hedging instrument used for legitimate price discovery of the underlying commodity reflected by supply and demand fundamentals in the marketplace.

Written By: Dian L. Chu, EconMatters

The views expressed are not FNArena's (see our disclaimer).

For real time news and analysis, please visit http://www.dailyfx.com/real_time_news

DailyFX provides forex news on the economic reports and political events that influence the currency market. Learn currency trading with a free practice account and charts from FXCM.

www.dailyfx.com

Disclaimer

Forex Capital Markets is headquartered at Financial Square 32 Old Slip, 10th Floor, New York, NY 10005 USA.

Trading foreign exchange on margin carries a high level of risk, and may not be suitable for all investors. The high degree of leverage can work against you as well as for you. Before you decide to trade the foreign exchange products offered by Forex Capital Markets, LLC, Forex Capital Markets Limited, inclusive of all EU branches, FXCM Asia Limited, or FXCM Australia Limited, any affiliates of aforementioned firms, or other firms under the FXCM group of companies [collectively “FXCM Group”] you should carefully consider your objectives, financial situation, needs and level of experience. If you decide to trade foreign exchange products offered by FXCM Australia Limited you must read and understand the Financial Services Guide and the Product Disclosure Statement. FXCM Group may provide general market information and commentary which is not intended to be investment advice and the content of this email must not be construed as personal advice. By trading, you could sustain a total loss of your deposited funds and therefore, you should not speculate with capital that you cannot afford to lose. You should be aware of all the risks associated with trading in foreign exchange products. Foreign exchange products are only suitable for those customers who fully understand the market risk. FXCM recommends you seek advice from a separate financial advisor.

FXCM Group assumes no liability for errors, inaccuracies or omissions in these materials and does not warrant the accuracy or completeness of the information, text, graphics, links or other items contained within these materials. FXCM Group shall not be liable for any special, indirect, incidental, or consequential damages, including without limitation losses, lost revenues, or lost profits that may result from these materials. This email is not a solicitation to buy or sell currency. All information contained in this e-mail is strictly confidential and is only intended for use by the recipient. All e-mail sent to or from this address will be received by the FXCM corporate e-mail system and is subject to archival and review by someone other than the recipient.”

Technical limitations

If you are reading this story through a third party distribution channel and you cannot see charts included, we apologise, but technical limitations are to blame.

FN Arena is building the future of financial news reporting at www.fnarena.com . Our daily news reports can be trialed at no cost and with no obligations. Simply sign up and get a feel for what we are trying to achieve.

Subscribers and trialists should read our terms and conditions, available on the website.

All material published by FN Arena is the copyright of the publisher, unless otherwise stated. Reproduction in whole or in part is not permitted without written permission of the publisher.